Business Details
29 Years
experience
Residential & Commercial Painting Experts in Columbus, OH
Established in 1997, Integrity Painting has built a reputation for delivering high-quality residential and commercial painting services rooted in core values of honesty and reliability. Founded by Dale Jagger and now led by Scott Russell since 2021, our team focuses on meticulous craftsmanship, including drywall repair, interior/exterior painting, and gutter installation since 2024. With over 70% of our business driven by referrals, we prioritize transparencyoffering detailed estimates, no upfront payments, and a 14-day post-project guarantee.Our employees undergo background checks and are trained in-house to ensure consistency, while our commitment to avoiding subcontractors guarantees direct accountability. Recognized by Angie's List and BBB, we combine decades of experience with modern techniques to meet client needs, from historical preservation to new construction, always adhering to safety and ethical standards.
Services
Interior Painting
Exterior Painting
Gutter Installation
Drywall Repair
Wood Replacement
Details
- Year established: 1997
Highlights and features
- Payment is required only after project completion
- 70% of clients from referrals and repeat customers
- All employees undergo background checks
- No subcontractors used for any projects
- Recognized on Angie's List and BBB with top ratings
What people say
Beautiful like new house
Excellent ratings
Peace of mind
Dedicated professionals
Top priority satisfaction
Services
Interior Painting
Our interior painting service transforms spaces with precision, offering detailed room analysis, color consultation, and preparation expertise. We handle trim work, drywall repairs, and multi-coat applications to ensure flawless finishes. From residential homes to commercial properties, our team balances efficiency with thoroughness, protecting furnishings and addressing hidden flaws for lasting results.
Gutter Installation
Specializing in 6-inch K-style seamless aluminum gutters, we address drainage needs while prioritizing structural integrity. Our installation includes facia and soffit replacement, underground drainage integration, and customized solutions for unique architectural challenges. We focus on durability and aesthetics to protect properties from water damage.
Drywall Repair
We restore walls with seamless drywall repairs, from minor dents to large-scale replacements. Our process involves sanding, taping, and backfilling seams to ensure smooth surfaces ready for painting. Clients benefit from our attention to detail during both repair and finishing stages.
Exterior Painting
This service revitalizes building exteriors through comprehensive assessments of siding types, structural height, and environmental factors. We employ ladders, lifts, and specialized equipment to ensure safety and access difficult areas, combining spray and brush techniques for optimal coverage and longevity.
Wood Replacement
We replace damaged wood elements with custom solutions, focusing on trim, molding, and structural components. Our team ensures material selection matches existing architecture while maintaining durability, particularly in conjunction with painting and gutter projects.
People
Scott Russell
Owner
Scott Russell acquired Integrity Painting in 2021, continuing its legacy of quality and ethical standards. With over two decades in the industry, he oversees operations and client relations while maintaining the company's founding principles.
Jason Gehr
Team Lead
Jason Gehr has led our team since 2001, bringing extensive expertise in painting techniques and project management. He ensures adherence to quality standards and mentors staff in best practices developed over two decades.
Jimmy Rector
Team Painter
Jimmy Rector joined Integrity Painting in 2018, specializing in precise interior and exterior applications. His attention to detail and commitment to finishing processes ensure consistently high-quality results across diverse projects.
Bransin Gehr
Team Painter
Bransin Gehr became part of our team in 2024, quickly mastering the Integrity approach to painting and repairs. He contributes to both residential and commercial projects, following established protocols for optimal outcomes.
Questions
Do you require upfront payments for painting projects?
No, we operate on a good faith system. Payment is collected only after project completion to your satisfaction.
What areas do you serve for residential painting?
We serve Columbus, OH and surrounding communities within a 50-mile radius including Johnstown, New Albany, and Delaware.
How are exterior painting estimates determined?
Exterior estimates consider siding type, structure height, roof accessibility, and square footage calculated from county records and Google Earth data.
Are your employees background-checked and trained?
Yes, all team members undergo background checks and receive in-house training to ensure consistent quality and adherence to our standards.
Do you handle gutter installation alongside painting?
Yes, we added seamless aluminum gutter installation in 2024, including facia/soffit replacement and drainage solutions.
Reviews (5)
Justin Molenaur
Apr 24, 2021
Report
We have used Integrity Painting multiple times at multiple properties and have always been satisfied. Dale is great to work with and we have to give high praise to Jason (supervisor) who ALWAYS goes above and beyond to make sure things are tip top. I wouldn't use anyone else to paint anything for me going forward.
Tammy Ellinwood
Jan 23, 2021
Report
These guys are the BEST in the business! They are honest, prompt, courteous and perfectionists when it comes to a doing a project! We've used Integrity Painting for years on several areas both inside and outside our home and would never look elsewhere! Dale is very fair on his pricing and he always makes sure that his customers are beyond happy when the project is completed. I can't say enough good things about this company! Matt and his crew that are currently working on a project at our home have truly done an amazing job so far and we cannot wait to see how beautiful everything looks when it's completed!
Brad Royalty
Jun 22, 2020
Report
They were working on my neighbors house and wanted to use my driveway to access difficult to reach areas. I said sure. After hearing several loud scratching noises, I ran outside to find they had backed equipment into the side of my home, scratching the brick. This was because my driveway is very narrow, and instead of taking a different approach, decided to jam the equipment through a very small opening.
They did this twice. Leaving scratch marks on my brick, twice. Dale, the owner, was leading this project that day and aware of this and said "I am doing the best I can." To be fair, Dale later knocked on my door and apologized. After my home being hit twice and Dale, the owner of "INTEGRITY painting" seemed annoyed with my complaints, I feel this review was necessary. I have left maybe 2 reviews ever, this story needed told to avoid this company. Dale has no respect for personal property and deserves to be outed for his dishonesty. Sorry Dale.
They did this twice. Leaving scratch marks on my brick, twice. Dale, the owner, was leading this project that day and aware of this and said "I am doing the best I can." To be fair, Dale later knocked on my door and apologized. After my home being hit twice and Dale, the owner of "INTEGRITY painting" seemed annoyed with my complaints, I feel this review was necessary. I have left maybe 2 reviews ever, this story needed told to avoid this company. Dale has no respect for personal property and deserves to be outed for his dishonesty. Sorry Dale.
Joel Van Horn
Jun 04, 2020
Report
I've hired Integrity Painting for two projects. The first time paint the entire interior after purchasing my home and the second time to paint a renovated bathroom. The finished work was great! I high recommend these guys.
T. Brennan
Mar 31, 2018
Report
We were very pleased with your service and will most certainly recommend Integrity Painting to anyone with confidence. Thank You!